THE JOURNAL OF EXPORT CONTROLS AND SANCTIONS

NEWS

Kiwi academics attack government catch-all proposals

November, 2019

‘Lack of clear guidance’ from government could bring ‘potentially chilling’ results.

Kiwi academics attack government catch-all proposals

In a submission to the New Zealand Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (‘MFAT’), a group of academics has criticised plans, outlined in a recent consultation, for the introduction of new catch-all controls. (For more on the consultation, see issue 84 of WorldECR).

In the public document, representatives of eight universities and a number of additional research groups said:

‘While we acknowledge the sentiment of the proposed regulatory changes, the proposal in its current form is unworkable. The lack of clear guidance as to what is and is not in scope of the policy creates potential for Government to be overly cautious in determining which technologies are encompassed – with a potentially chilling impact on valuable research and knowledge sharing.’

The academics argue that as a result of that ‘lack of clear guidance’, researchers ‘may simply decide that only the most extreme technologies fall within scope – with the effect that the policy fails in its objectives,’ and that research organisations ‘simply cannot predict what all technologies will be used for in the future and therefore cannot be held accountable for failing to do so.’

Nor, say the academics, ‘can research organisations identify all the military or other affiliations of offshore entities or individuals. MFAT is in a much better position to do this and need to take greater responsibility and accountability for assessing technology risk and vetting offshore collaborators/partners/purchasers.’

 

See: https://www.universitiesnz.ac.nz/sites/default/files/uni-nz/documents/UNZ_Kiwinet_ScienceNZ_IRANZ_%20MFAT_export_controls_submission_12_Nov_0.pdf

 

 

Find an Export Controls Expert
SIGN UP FOR WORLDECR ALERTS

SUBSCRIBE NOW TO RECEIVE


Password Reset
Please enter your e-mail address. You will receive a new password via e-mail.